Nikki Gonzalez
2024-02-24 23:52:05 GMT
Came here about a week ago the food was fantastic! I ordered Chicken Marsala and it was so authentic & delicious! It’s hard to find good Italian food around here but this place was very good ! Our waitress went above and beyond to provide our services, I have a disabled son and he was being quite difficult but the waitress took good care of us and helped out a lot , was very patient ! I didn’t catch her name but she was blonde and said she was new , also there was a very nice bus girl that packed our food for us we asked for boxes and she went out her way to do it for us I thought that was very sweet .
My only complaints is they took out the bar but other than that the food is still delicious! Whoever the new owner is did a good job on keeping the excellent reputation. Anyone who has anything bad to say about this place is crazy !
Tialisa Whipple
2022-09-22 22:39:57 GMT
I have to say the best thing about this place is the staff. The food was good the atmosphere fine but the waitstaff was exceptional. Very attentive, funny without being obnoxious and friendly. Our waitress made us feel like family. I love that! This restaurant is literally a stones throw from my house so it's a go to whenever I don't want to cook. There are other restaurants just as close, but I choose Casa Mia. You can tell they are all working hard at building a successful business and the staff reflects it. My favorite dish here is the broilded pork chops with a side of fresh green beans.
Kerry Sullivan
2023-05-21 15:37:02 GMT
Casa Mia Hurleyville hosted my graduation party and it was amazing! 😁 They let us arrive early to decorate.The food was delicious, the staff was wonderful and so helpful, and everything that went into the planning was easy. The cost was surprisingly reasonable. I will definitely consider them again 🥰
Thank you for making a wonderful evening go smoothly!
Steve W
2024-02-11 08:54:22 GMT
Been eating at this establishment for 15 years and the portions are unbelievable and delicious. I always bring guests and everyone is always satisfied. Everyone loves the chicken parm.
Alex Nowro
2024-02-22 19:31:19 GMT
We ate inside, food was warm. Lots of leftovers to take home. We had knots, pizza and clam sauce over pasta... delicious
Karen Northrup
2022-08-22 18:51:55 GMT
Service was great! The food was delicious and nice portions.
Robin
2023-12-11 21:53:53 GMT
Love the shrimp and tomato sauce over linguine! The portions are huge, definitely enough to take some home for tomorrows lunch. Salad is fresh. Staff are friendly and professional. Get the garlic bread!! Calamari appetizer has the best crust and is perfectly tender! Large selection of beverages and desserts packed to go!
APRIL RENEE
2024-01-04 23:47:36 GMT
Food amazing service ahh. Many to go orders. Food service slow but worth the wait
Kittinun Sriprasertying
2019-10-18 00:23:50 GMT
Service is quite slow but the taste and value of the food is super duper. Veal milanese, hicken parm and shrimp pasta is super delish. Pizza is huge and loaded for only $15.
Mike Panekowski
2023-08-13 11:09:53 GMT
We decided on Italian foods for dinner and although there are several choices in the Monticello area we all chose Momma Mia resturant,
If you or any member of your dinner party is really hungry then Momma Mia resturant is the place to go to end the hunger!!!
The dinner plates are ENORMOUS and unless you or that specific party member is a black bear chances are none of you will be finishing your entire dinner plate as the plates are loaded with food.
The prices range from the mid teens to the lower 30's which is comparable to most every other resturant prices so if your on a budget and you want value for your money spent then by all means this is where you need to go as once you are completed with your meal chances are you will be bringing leftovers home which will most likely translate into another meal so essentially your getting 2 meals for the price of one!!
All meals are served with a fresh garden salad and the main meal arrives with your choice of a side dish of pasta or fries or veggies and the table will also have a nice large bread basket with butter as well,
The atmosphere is very pleasant and the wait staff are all extremely willing to offer themselves to any needs you or your party may need.
The resturant has large tables to accomodate big parties and theres plenty of room with no wait as you will be seated shortly after arrival,
If your looking for a great Italian dinner that gives great value for the price then you need to come to Momma mia.....
Sierra
2022-12-09 00:49:50 GMT
We primarily order take out from Casa Mia but we’ve dined in as well! We’ve had a great experience every time. The hoagies (subs) are our favorite! Great portion size if you order the chicken parm. Pizza is yummy as well.
Rita VanFluke
2023-03-13 13:33:10 GMT
Casa Mia ( formerly Frankie and Johnny's) is a wonderful little Italian restaurant in Hurleyville.
Not much in the way of atmosphere, but the food is fantastic! Servers are friendly and very helpful. It's a great family restaurant.
Rhonda Bischert
2023-07-23 22:51:16 GMT
Great food, great service, great people, that was three years ago. Today 7/23/2023 we order chicken Parm sandwich, antipasto salad and there baked clams. We was very disappointed for the first time. The clams seemed to be premade and frozen, the sauce was different, and the house dressing was not good at all.
Rory Lisefski
2022-05-28 22:57:49 GMT
It’s the same as Frankie and Johnnies. I grew up going there, my father was actually one of the first customers when they opened. The food is part of my life. I was concerned when I saw the name change but one noseful walking in and my mind was settled. The prices seem a little lower but the portions are a little smaller. Not a big deal, F&Js had insane portions so even being smaller it’s too much. Don’t worry about the signage, if you want a good meal go.
Paul Reining
2020-01-05 15:52:16 GMT
Our first time dining at Nardi's. It was everything I was told and more. Awesome Italian food, and huge portions! Staff is very friendly and accommodating. Definitely worth the drive, we'll be returning!
Randall Grimm, Jr.
2018-02-27 17:52:23 GMT
By far my favorite Italian restaurant in Sullivan county. The food is delicious, portions are large, the wait staff is great, and the owner is a friendly guy if you get the chance to meet him. Never had a bad meal here. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone who loves great Italian food. The menu options are very extensive.
Jesse Goodman
2021-10-10 02:18:45 GMT
This used to be Franky and Johnny’s and also nardis before the owners sold the place and always had the best Italian food and guess what? The food is exactly the same great food they always had and the same waitress (forgot her name but knew my family for a long time) and the same great scenery! Please come out and support!
Billie Jo Bergeron
2018-05-31 02:09:04 GMT
I have never had a bad experience here. The food is - Amazing! True italian, fresh and portions are huge!! We had salad orders delivered before we ordered our dinners. Salad, bread, dinner, pasta, and we had an appetizer as well. Truly a great experience and in rural area. Worth the drive.
Mindy Butler
2022-10-07 13:38:06 GMT
The food is the original food from the old Frankie and Johnny's as well as the server absolutely great experience! The waitress was very good with my mother that has dementia I highly recommend this restaurant
Oscar Mindrutiu
2018-06-27 01:23:57 GMT
Ate here numerous times and each time was even better than the last. Phenomenal chicken, veal and pasta dishes. Will try a seafood dish next time for sure. Family feel and the staff was very courteous. Prices are very fair. Definitely recommended.
